| 2027 | Parker Hodge | National Merit Semifinalist (Pending) |
| Luke Juhas | National Merit Semifinalist (Pending) |
| Everett Raybourn | National Merit Semifinalist (Pending) |
| 2026 | Maya Chavan | National Merit Commended Student |
| Kristen Gaubert | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2025 | Aidan Baker | National Merit Commended Student |
| Antonio El-Sayah | National Hispanic Recognition |
| George Golubev | National Merit Commended Student |
| Victoria Lee | National Hispanic Recognition |
| Ace London | National Merit Commended Student |
| Emma Thompson | National Merit Scholar |
| Rowan Wilson | National First-Generation Recognition |
| 2024 | Mariana Contreras Fernandez | National Merit Scholar |
| Mariana Contreras Fernandez | National Hispanic Recognition |
| Sophia Dosev | National Hispanic Recognition |
| Nathaniel Flores | National Merit Commended Student |
| Grant Robertson | National Merit Commended Student |
| Rex Rogers | National Hispanic Recognition |
| 2023 | Alexandra Foland | National Merit Finalist |
| Porter Hanley | National Merit Semifinalist |
| Luke Junck | National Merit Finalist |
| Virginia Myers | National Merit Commended Student |
| Elizabeth Owens | National Merit Finalist |
| Sophia Royles | National Merit Finalist |
| Tyler Ruble | National Merit Finalist |
| Jacob Seaman | National Merit Commended Student |
| Caroline Struck | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2022 | Alexis Dillard | National African-American Recognition |
| Alexis Dillard | National Hispanic Recognition |
| Maggie Johnson | National Merit Commended Student |
| Hailey Lewis-Steffensmeier | National African-American Recognition |
| 2021 | Joseph Baroco | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2020 | John Nusbaum | National Merit Scholar |
| 2019 | Quinten Endacott | National Merit Commended Student |
| Eleanor Provosty | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2018 | Brian Branstetter | National Merit Commended Student |
| Sophia Hermann | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Luke Stringfellow | National Merit Commended Student |
| Patrick Wabnitz | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2017 | Blakeley Baker | National Merit Commended Student |
| Matthew Reynolds | National Merit Finalist |
| Annie Snyder | National Merit Commended Student |
| Reed Taylor | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2016 | Gabrielle Dosev | National Merit Commended Student |
| Richard Fell | National Merit Finalist |
| Jared Knorr | National Merit Commended Student |
| Eric Masterson | National Merit Commended Student |
| Alexa McKnight | National Merit Commended Student |
| Megan Morrison | National Merit Commended Student |
| Joseph Nusbaum | National Merit Commended Student |
| Caroline Sears | National Merit Commended Student |
| Daniell Sullivan | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2015 | Hannah Branstetter | National Merit Commended Student |
| Maria Gund | National Merit Finalist |
| Nicholas Heseman | National Merit Commended Student |
| Troy Stringfellow | National Merit Finalist |
| Case Wagner | National Merit Semifinalist |
| 2014 | Bronson Chancellor | National Merit Commended Student |
| John Chope | National Merit Commended Student |
| Mallory Herrmann | National Merit Commended Student |
| Joseph Snyder | National Merit Commended Student |
| Jacob Williams | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2012 | Katherine Driscoll | National Merit Commended Student |
| Erin Hart | National Merit Commended Student |
| Kiera McDonald | National Merit Commended Student |
| 2008 | Timothy Dziadon | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Mark Gibson | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Julie Hoffman | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Elizabeth Kummer | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Stefan Lee | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Shannon Williams | National Merit Finalist |
| James Wilson | National Achievement Scholar |
| 2007 | Caitlin Greskovich | National Merit Finalist |
| 2004 | Jesse Barksdale | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Elizabeth Bell | National Merit Commended Scholar |
| Matthew Gibson | National Merit Finalist |
| 2003 | Michael Gibson | National Merit Commended Student |
| Christopher Holcomb | National Merit Commended Student |
| Emily Jones | National Merit Commended Student |
| Jessica Kane | National Merit Finalist |
| Jessica Libbey | National Merit Commended Student |
| Charles Neal | National Merit Commended Student |
| Andrew Reeves | National Merit Finalist |
| Michael Stackhouse | National Merit Finalist |
| 2002 | Craig Jabaley | National Merit Finalist |
| Bennett Stackhouse | National Merit Finalist |
| Elizabeth Summers | National Merit Finalist |
| 2001 | Elizabeth Bates | National Merit Finalist |
| Tamara Squalls | National Achievement Commended Student |
| 2000 | John Getty | National Merit Finalist |
| Angela Priest | National Merit Finalist |
| Richard Whitney | National Merit Finalist |
| 1999 | Lauren Alsop | National Merit Commended Student |
| Lindsey Decoteau | National Merit Commended Student |
| Jennifer Luetkemeyer | National Merit Finalist |
| Carrie McGugin | National Merit Finalist |
| 1998 | Betsy Brown | National Merit Commended Student |
| J.W. Bulger | National Merit Commended Student |
| Matt Feeks | National Merit Commended Student |
| Elizabeth Foscue | National Merit Finalist |
| Matt Galloway | National Merit Commended Student |
| Matthew Lewis | National Merit Finalist |
| Michael McDonald | National Merit Finalist |
| Michael Rubey | National Merit Semifinalist |
| 1996 | Anna Fabrega | National Merit Scholar |
| Samantha Jackson | National Merit Commended Student |
| Kevin McDonald | National Merit Scholar |
| 1995 | Jeff Butler | National Merit Commended Student |
| Jackson George | National Merit Commended Student |
| Cassie Hobgood | National Merit Commended Student |
| Nicki Squalls | Nationally Commended Black Student |
| 1994 | Ahsha Bell | Nationally Commended Black Student |
| Jason Keith | National Merit Commended Student |
| Matt Kimmel | National Merit Semifinalist |
| Jill Reinauer | National Merit Commended Student |
| 1993 | Tommy Baroco | National Merit Commended Student |
| Michael Cancellare | National Merit Commended Student |
| Kristen Riley | National Merit Commended Student |
| Bridget Sowinski | National Merit Commended Student |
| 1989 | Matt McCandless | National Merit Semifinalist |
| 1986 | Vinh Bui | National Merit Commended Student |
| Wendy Kaiser | National Merit Commended Student |
| Walter Pierce | Outstanding Negro Student |
| Mary Whitney | National Merit Semifinalist |
